The last scraps of hope I had for this song were resting on the possibility that if I had the actual disc in my hand, and gave it a few spins on the stereo, something I was overlooking before would hit me, and suddenly I'd start to like it.
Or at the very least, I'd start to hate it less.
Four listens later though, I realised that just wasn't going to happen. Simply put, it's a bad song. It's flat, charmless, and forgettable- the sound of two session musicians idly passing time in the studio. If I ever listen to this song again, it certainly won't be for a while. There's no doubt that It'll turn up on album three of course, and thinking about it, it will probably fit in fairly well next to producer
Yusuke Tanaka's other anime tie-in
Tip Taps Tip. I really hope this is the last time Sony will use
Halcali to plug a TV show in this way, but the chances are
Tanaka's planning the next forgettable installment already.
Or, could just be that the A and B sides just got mixed up in the pressing plant?
i-dep's Hiroshi Nakamura's fourth
Halcali song,
Sister Ship, is the real draw here- it's a big, catchy, addictive pop song that has the good sense to actually have a chorus that can, and will, be stuck in your head like bubblegum for weeks to come. It's exactly the type of song that
Halcali are best at and sound most comfortable doing, but sadly it's also the type of thing that a lot of producers have been mysteriously reluctant to let them loose on recently. At just over 5 minutes, it's probably a bit too long, and vocoder effects in songs have now totally worn out their welcome, but it's still everything that
LOOK isn't. It's certainly good enough to warrent the price of the single alone, making this much more than the 'loyalty purchase' I thought it was going to be. See if you can figure out what "fisher hip" means, too.
So continues
Nakamura's winning streak. The quality of all of his songs up to now have been more than enough that I would've been happy to have any of them as tracks on the third album. It's tragic to think that a song as good as
check!! check!! it!! ended up on the back of
Twinkle Star, a single no one heard.
Tips Taps Tip sold better, but aren't both
Halcali 'n' Bass and
Peace Dream wasted as b-sides?
If
OTF really have parted ways with
Halcali, I'd be happy to see
Nakamura come in and fill in that big brother gap. Let's have him all over the next album, please.
About the DVD: It's worth getting the limited edition version of the single for the DVD (if only to own it), but it's no great shakes. It just contains the
Gatochou song from
Tanaka Teacher (it's been on
YouTube for a while and I don't think it's been removed yet). It's sadly missing the great video for
LOOK, and they couldn't even be bothered to come up with a menu screen. Considering the price is 200-odd yen more, it's disappointing.